The NHL Instigator Rule, And What The League Needs To Do With It

May 15, 2009

by Derek Harmsworth…

First, a confession, I hate the instigator rule.

I don’t hate it because it discourages retaliation, or late game fights.  I don’t hate it because in some cases it allows the league’s pest to hide behind the rule while running amok on the ice.

No, there is a completely different reason I hate the NHL’s instigator rule.

With all due respect to the league’s officials, they simply have no idea how to use it properly, which seriously puts a dent into its credibility and raises questions to its mere existence.

All of this would be a moot point if it weren’t for a recent trend that has developed this season: players who throw clean hits, and then have to answer the bell in terms of a fight.

While this trend is not the biggest issue in hockey right now, it is becoming an annoyance. Furthermore, I think if you look back to all those instances in which a player had to defend himself in a fight following a clean hit, you will find one similarity. There likely was not an instigator rule handed out in any of the cases.

By definition, and I will be paraphrasing here, a player instigates a fight when he drops the gloves first, or grabs another player, and begins throwing punches without the other player having a say in the matter.

Saturday night’s game between the Toronto Maple Leafs and the Pittsburgh Penguins is another example in the latest saga of instigator misuse.

After Leafs’ defenseman Luke Schenn delivered a solid, yet perfectly legal, hit on Evgeni Malkin, Tyler Kennedy, who had come off the bench in the midst of a post-whistle line change, grabbed Schenn and began a shoving match, which escalated into a fight.

Coming off the bench, grabbing a player, and getting into a fight breaks a few rules, but apparently the instigator rule is not one of them.

For the record, Kennedy has been suspended for one game by the NHL for coming off the bench and engaging in a fight.

And while I hope people don’t look at this as pro-Leafs banter, the time is now for the NHL to decide where to go with the instigator rule.

Do they keep it? And if they do, will they finally begin to enforce it properly?

While it seems to be on the agenda at every general managers meeting, the time may finally come for the league to take a serious look at the rule, and whether it serves a purpose in today’s NHL.

All of this will surely be a double-edged sword considering the talk of banning fighting all together.

Kimbo Slice Looks to Boxing for One Last Chance

May 15, 2009

By Stoker MacIntosh… The Miami Herald announced today that Kimbo Slice—the exiled MMA fighter who was knocked out cold in one punch by part time fighter Seth Petruzelli last year—is scheduled to make his pro boxing debut sometime this Summer.

Important to note however that this news is coming via boxing promoter Gary Shaw —and quite frankly—if Shaw tells me that the sun is shining, I’m likely to go look for myself. Let’s just say that the man’s credibility has been questioned on more than one occasion.

So according to Shaw, Slice—who’s birth certificate says Kevin Ferguson—will make his heavyweight boxing debut, and it wouldn’t take the great Sherlock Holmes to figure out who his promoter will likely be.

The date, venue and opponent however—have all, as of yet—not been determined.

The Miami Herald was also reporting Thursday that the former street-fighting star is no longer contractually tied to Strikeforce—the San Jose-based organization who purchased Slice’s contract, along with 41 other EliteXC fighter contracts, earlier this year.

So that further opens the door to Shaw, who will undoubtedly keep trying to make some spare change from the Kimbo name.

Coming straight from the horses mouth earlier this year, the Nassau Guardian quoted Slice as saying this: “Boxing is really my first desire. I have a lot of love for it and believe I can do pretty well at it.”

Slice also said, “MMA is somewhat of a project for me. Boxing is one dimensional while there are a lot of dimensions in MMA. I don’t think it would be a hard transition from MMA to stand-up boxing because of my fighting style, he said.”

The MMA knockout of Slice made headlines around the world mainly due to the fighters manufactured stardom by MMA promotion Elite XC—who gambled the farm on a long shot that he would be their version of Mike Tyson.

Now, it seems to me that they had built unsurmountable odds for a guy with zero amateur background or formal training, but as far as my opinion goes, I’m very reluctant to jump on the Kimbo-hater bandwagon.

The stage was set, the curtains were pulled, and Kimbo—a mere mortal—made the best of his grand entrance, the onus for Kimbo’s Box-Office-bomb belongs to Shaw.

Actually, it’s not unlike the biblical proverb regarding the foolish man who built his house upon the sand.

Shaw and Elite XC’s future depended on the weak foundation of a man who’s only claim to fame was his you-tube Internet footage. When Slice fell to the canvas the fate of the organization fell with him.

Now don’t get me wrong, I am a fight fan first and foremost, and I love to see fighters succeed..but once again we are hearing the names of Kimbo and Shaw spoken in the same sentence, and that cant be good for boxing, no matter how you Slice it.

Genius may have its limitations, but stupidity is not thus handicapped. Elbert Hubbard
US author (1856 - 1915)

CC Sabathia delivers as Blue Jays lose rubber match

May 15, 2009

By English Paul…

With the sun shining and the roof open for the first time this season, it was all set up for the Toronto Blue Jays to prove that they were serious contenders by passing their first big test of this young season and defeating the New York Yankees to win the series.

Unfortunately CC Sabathia (3-3) had other ideas as he continued his recent improvement, throwing 111 pitches through eight innings.  Mariano Rivera came into the game for the ninth and recorded three quick outs to clinch the save for the Bronx Bombers.  Hideki Matsui set up the win by breaking a 2-2 tie in the eighth inning, hitting his fourth home run of the season off Jesse Carlson (0-2).

Brian Tallet delivered his third successive quality start for Toronto, after overcoming a nightmare first inning.  The Oklahoma native walked three batters, the last of which gave New York a 1-0 lead.  In total, it took 24 pitches to get out of the inning.

After this, Tallet recovered impressively, only giving up three further hits and helping Toronto take a 2-1 lead, heading into the seventh.  The two runs came courtesy of an Alex Rios homer in the fourth and a Rod Barajas RBI double in the fifth.

The key turning point of the game came in the seventh inning after a walk had moved Brett Gardner to first.  A Francisco Cervelli single wrong-footed John McDonald and the chance for the double play was gone, with Gardner advancing to third base.  This signalled the end of Tallet’s evening as he was replaced by Carlson.  Two pitches later, a Derek Jeter RBI single tied the game at two.

Later on in the locker room, despite admitting that he could not find the zone in the first inning, Tallet felt that it was the walk in the seventh that had cost Toronto.  “To me, that was the difference in the game.”   He went on to add, “I gave myself a chance to win, gave our team a chance to win, but once again it goes back to that walk and more than anything I was just disappointed in myself.”

Speaking to Cito Gaston in his office after the game, the coach was asked about facing Sabathia.  “He’s a good pitcher.  Tallet hung in there with him as long as he could.  Overall, except for us not winning, it was a pretty good game.”

The defeat marks the first time that Toronto has lost a series at home this season, as well as their first back-to-back defeats at Rogers Centre.  It will be interesting to see how the Blue Jays respond, as they prepare to face the Chicago White Sox tonight in the first of a four game series.

Paul Taylor can be contacted at: [email protected]

Wake UP with the Hotties of Hockey (Part 1)

May 15, 2009

It’s the final four, the semi-finals in the NHL. It’s come down to four teams. Chicago vs. Detroit and Pittsburg vs. Carolina. Who you got? Make your predictions now! It just doesn’t get much better than this. For more of your ice hockey entertainment, I bring you The Hotties of Hockey Part 1.

Richard Gasquet: Many Sides to the Same Coin

May 15, 2009

By Long John Silver… Bonjour

If we are true to the most romantic language in the world we would pronounce his name in English as – ‘Reee-Shhhhard Gasquet’. How many times have we wondered that if only we can combine one particular player’s physical ability, with another players’ psychological prowess we would have a multiple slam champion in our hand.

Every time I have watched Safin or Ree-Shard, time and again I have thought ‘Damm, all they need is a little bit of that Lleyton-ness, the vintage bloody-mindedness in ‘em’. I have thought the same thing about their physical ability and how Lleyton would have fared if he had that too.

I fondly remembered my Halloween post last year, Ree-Shard was the Prince

Ree-Shard—never the one to relish pressure but with one of the most artistic game and single-fisted backhands in the game. His eternal disinclination to pressure is highlighted by the fact that he never relished playing in front of his home French crowd (he pulled out last year citing physical reasons, but played a tournament just a week after?).

His Davis Cup meltdowns against the U.S. have been documented very well before. His capacity to hit a tennis ball around incomparably exquisite, is indicated by his legendary two-sets-and-a-break-down comeback against ROD in London SW19 quarterfinal. But those comebacks have been few and far.

There is nothing more frustrating than possessing all the ability in the world, only to watch it go futile because of what goes on between the ears in the head. Being termed ‘Baby-FED’ is hardly justifiable.

The game lost one of its most elegant, brash players, and one of my most favorite players to Cocaine two years before, in the name of Martina Hingis (to this very day, I miss Hingis and her toothy smile and brashness). Here is the problem. Cocaine is not a performance enhancing drug, it never has been.

If anything, using it makes you all ‘woozy’ after a while. That’s the last thing you want to feel at RG when Rafael is drilling hook forehands from outside the doubles alley for clean winners.

Neither is he a doctor operating on your dad or sister after lighting a smoke up in the men’s room at the hospital. That way, you have all the prerogative to say, ‘Mate, he controls my dad’s life…and hence I want him to be not strung over coke in the hospital’. But he isn’t a doctor.

The liberal in me asks, how is it different from prostitution? As unsavory it is, prostitution is considered a crime in our society, but it is a victimless crime. The prostitute gets paid for her work, the perpetrator gets sex is return, no one is injured—victimless crime.

Ree-Shard pulled out of Miami citing a shoulder injury. The fact that he used cocaine is dicey, but the purpose of drug rules is to stop athletes from gaining unfair advantage (steroids?). Tennis is significantly cleaner than baseball or football any day and we intend to keep it that way for a long time.

The magnitude of difference between tennis and baseball is as clear as light and day. Jon Wertheim does the research and reports that tennis has an incredibly stringent threshold for recreational drugs.

The cocaine allowed in your blood level is four times lower for tennis,than if you want to enroll yourself in the U.S. military. The question come down to—is the rule serving the intended purpose. Is this threshold serving the purpose of preventing athletes from gaining an unfair advantage on court?

I definitely do see the other side of the story. Top athletes are expected to be clean. Parents around the world claim ‘I definitely want Gasquet punished because if you don’t punish him for smoking Cocaine, it sends  a message to my kid that its OK to do that’.

I see that and am not insular to athletes owning up to their social responsibilities. Then comes the next question, should tennis even test for recreational drugs? Why bother testing for it, if it’s not performance-enhancing? It only becomes a problem if its divulged, so why test for it in the first place when it does not serve the purpose of the rule?

Where do you draw the line, though; he certainly cannot light a smoke during a tournament, it’s just something to avoid. So you test him just during the tournament?  These drugs stay in the blood for months, you can never clearly determine when it got into his physiological system.

Or should we say, no drug in any form, shape or purpose is allowed? Is that fair?

Tough questions.

There is another thought that Ree-Shard can use the time off to get is career back on track. Make no mistake he is still in the top echelons of the game… but he was destined to be higher—a multiple slam champion which he isn’t, that school of thought says, he is better off with this time to introspect and focus more on what really is important in his career.

There are many sides to this coin, the actual underlying problems have got as much to do with sport, as they are with our societal morals?

Penguins’ Crosby, Coyotes’ Balsillie: Most Popular Canucks Since Gretzky

May 15, 2009

By Martin Avery… It’s hockey icon night and day in Canada, thanks to Sidney Crosby and Jim Balsillie.

Sidney Crosby, captain and leading scorer of the Pittsburgh Penguins, is enormously popular in Canada, and his popularity is soaring after his performance in Game Seven of the Stanley Cup Playoffs.

Crosby scored two goals, added an assist, and his Penguins beat Alex Ovechkin and the Washington Capitals 6-2. They chased rookie goalie Simeon Varlamov form the Caps net.

The Penguins are enormously popular in Pittsburgh these days, too, but a few years ago the franchise was in trouble and Jim Basillie offered to buy the team and move the Penguins to Canada.

To think it might be Sidney Crosby and the Hamilton Penguins heading for the Stanley Cup finals this year—and last year, too.

Now Balsillie is about as popular as Crosby in Canada for trying to move another NHL team north of the border. An incredible outpouring of support has met his attempt to turn the Phoenix Coyotes into the Hamilton Tigers.

Balsillie wants to bring Wayne Gretzky back to Canada, as the coach of the franchise, and re-name the Hamilton arena after another Canadian icon, the coach’s father, Walter Gretzky.

When Sidney Crosby and the Penguin’s play Wayne Gretzky’s Hamilton Tigers at the Walter Gretzky arena, it will definitely be hockey icon night in Canada.

If that happens, Balsillie could not be more popular in Canada if he gave everybody in the country a free BlackBerry.